Sudras in Ancient India tries to show how the labouring class in ancient times came to be known as sudras. It explores their social and economic relations with the members of the higher varnas. It also tries to tackle several other problems: Was ancient Indian society a slave society? How far did the ritual status of the sudras correspond to their economic status? How did the vaisyas come to be reduced to the level of the sudras and the sudras placed on a par with the vaisyas? What accounts for the proliferation of the servile orders in Gupta and post-Gupta times? Why were social revolts comparatively absent in ancient India?
Although the study hinges on the history of the sudras, it also works out a framework for the history of social differentiation and marks the main stages in the evolution of ancient Indian society. Since social history cannot be studied without appreciating material life, at various stages the impact of settled agricultural life, thriving trade, and land grants on the social formation has been made with developments in other ancient societies and also with tribal practices and institutions known to anthropology.
About the Author:
Professor R.S. Sharma (b. 1920) was mostly educated in the institutions affiliated to Patna University, under which he taught for 30 years till 1973 when he moved to Delhi University. He retired from Delhi University in 1985 and is now Emeritus Professor of History at Patna University. He did his Ph.D. at the School of Oriental and African Studies where he also served as a research associate. He was also a visiting professor at the University of Toronto. He was the first chairman of the Indian Council of Historical Research. His well-known book Ancient India (1977) was withdrawn by the Indian Government under the pressure of obscurantist elements in May 1978. Sharma's other publications include Indian Feudalism: 300-1200 (1980); Perspectives in Social and Economic History of Early India (1983); Material Culture and Social Formations In Ancient India (1983); Urban Decay in India (c. 300-c.1000), (1987); Communal History and Rama's Ayodhya (1992); Aspects of India Political Ideas and Institutions in Ancient India(1995); Looking for the Aryans (1995); The State and Varna Formation in the Mid-Ganga Plains (1996) and Early Medieval Indian Society (2001). His publications appear in fifteen languages, Indian and non-Indian.
Excerpts From Reviews:
This is an outstanding piece of research and authentic history of Sudras in ancient India. Professor Sharma has made use of all published sources, literary as well as archaeological, bearing on the social and economic position of Sudras. It gives a lucid and comprehensive account of all aspects of the anguished career of Sudra community.
L.M. Joshi
Journal of Religious Studies
Vol. 10, No. I & II, 1982
The facility and confidence with which Sharma makes his arguments and conclusions comforting, it weaves together scattered references into the first connected account of the Sudra varna and places this within a broader historical framework.
Upendra Singh
Contribution to Indian Sociology,
Vol.26, No.1, Jan-June, 1992
Sharma co-relates the phases of economic development with social organization and social change. He rightly calls the Rigvedic society as 'basically tribal', pastoral and egalitarian and 'a pre-class society' and contends that 'the defeated and disposed sections of Aryans and Non-aryan tribes were reduced to the position of Sudras'. The later-vedic society was food producing and agricultural, but their agricultural technology was primitive; consequently differentiation between haves and have-nots could not be intensified The Sudras continued to form the labour force of a labour-intensive economy; they also supplied surplus produce as peasants. There were no violent social upheavals because their minds were enchained by the Karma theory.
In ancient India, the cultural apparatus of the Sudras, more so of the untouchables or the 'asat' Sudra, was very primitive, consequently their response was usually of abject submission.
S.N. Mishra
The Eastern Anthropologist
Vol. 37, No. 4, Oct.-Dec. 1984
Preface to the Second Edition | v | |
Preface to the First Edition | vii | |
Abbreviations | ix | |
Roman Equivalents of Nagari letters | xiii | |
Chapters | ||
I. | Historiography and Approach | |
Western interest in ancient Indian society | 1 | |
The place of the sudras in writings on ancient society | 1 | |
Stating the questions and indicating the method | 3 | |
II. | Origin | |
Racial import of arya | 9 | |
Difference between the Dasas and Dasyus | 10 | |
Fight between the Aryan and the pre-Aryan tribes | 12 | |
Inter-tribal struggle among the Aryans | 16 | |
The Panis | 19 | |
Social adjustment between the Aryans and the pre-Aryan chalcolithic people | 21 | |
Das as 'Aryan' tribe/slave in the age of Rigveda | 24 | |
Mass migration of the Aryans attested by linguistic evidence and also by archaeology | 27 | |
Absence of sharp class divisions in Rigvedic society | 29 | |
High status of artisans | 31 | |
The Purusasukta and the sudras as a social order | 32 | |
Sudras as a tribe | 35 | |
Sudras as an Aryan tribe | 37 | |
Were the sudras originally ksatriyas? | 40 | |
Etymological derivation of the term sudra | 42 | |
The status of the sudra-varna at the time of its origin | 44 | |
III. | Tribes verses Varna (c. 1000 - 500 B.C.) | |
Later Vedic literature and Painted Grey Ware archaeology | 46 | |
Sudras as serving class | 48 | |
Sudras as 'serfs' and 'slaves' | 52 | |
Dignity of manual work | 53 | |
Sudras ratnins in the royal coronation | 54 | |
Sudras in the rajasuya rituals | 56 | |
Sudra soldiers in the asvamedha sacrifice | 59 | |
King's desire for the support of all the four varnas | 61 | |
Exclusion of the sudra from some coronation rituals | 62 | |
An Aitareya Brahmanapassage regarding the sudras | 64 | |
Marital relations between the higher varnas and sudras/slaves | 68 | |
Beginning of the assimilation of non-Aryan tribes | 71 | |
The sudra and upanayana | 73 | |
The sudra and Vedic sacrifice | 78 | |
Sudras's participation in some religious rites | 79 | |
Gods worshipped by the sudras | 81 | |
Greater evidence against the sudras participation in the Vedic sacrifice | 83 | |
Contradiction in the position of the sudras | 87 | |
Material culture and constraints on class formation | 88 | |
IV. | Servility and Disabilities (c. 600 - c. 300 B.C.) | |
Nature of the Dharmasutras and early Pali texts | 90 | |
Material background from NBP archaeology | 95 | |
Appropriation of land and labour | 96 | |
Clear definition of the sudras as a serving class | 98 | |
Crafts and craftsmen | 99 | |
Sudras as agricultural labourers | 102 | |
Slaves and hired labourers in production | 103 | |
Living conditions of the sudras | 106 | |
Dasas, pessas, kammakaras and bhatakas | 108 | |
Economic disabilities according to the Dharmasutras | 112 | |
Sudras as primary producers; their living standards | 114 | |
Comparison with Greek slaves and helots | 116 | |
Political-legal discriminations | 116 | |
Social disabilities | 124 | |
Exclusion from the rite of upanayana and from education | 133 | |
Exclusion from sacrifices and sacraments | 134 | |
Contempt of the higher varnas for manual occupations | 137 | |
Five despised castes of the early Pali texts | 138 | |
Origin of untouchability | 144 | |
Religious reforming movements and the sudras | 146 | |
End of the ambiguous position of the sudras | 152 | |
Sudras reaction to disabilities | 154 | |
V. | State Control and the Servile Order (c.300 - c. 200 B.C.) | |
The date and authenticity of the Arthasastra of Kautilya | 157 | |
The meaning of the term sudrakarsakapraya | 161 | |
Slaves and agricultural labourers in state production | 163 | |
Employment, control and wages of the artisans | 166 | |
High posts as the preserve of the three higher varnas | 172 | |
Sudras as spies and soldiers | 173 | |
Varna legislation of Kautilya | 174 | |
Status of the sudra vis-à-vis slaves in Kautilya | 177 | |
Dasa and ahitaka | 178 | |
Manumission and treatments of slaves | 179 | |
Mauryan society, a slave-owning society | 182 | |
Asoka's vyavahara-samata and danda-samata | 183 | |
Marriage practices of the sudras and the formation of mixed castes | 184 | |
Religious condition of the sudras | 187 | |
General conduct of the lower orders | 189 | |
VI. | Crisis in the Old Order (c. 200 B.C. - c. A.D. 300) | |
Sources for the post-Mauryan period | 191 | |
Manu on the approximation of the sudras with vaisyas | 192 | |
Artisans in the context of commerce and handicraft | 195 | |
Epigraphic and literary records on artisans | 199 | |
Manu's economic measures against the sudras | 201 | |
Wages and living conditions of the labourers | 204 | |
Adverse position of the sudras in law and polity | 207 | |
Severe punishments for sudras offending against members of the superior varnas | 211 | |
Discrimination against the sudra regarding inheritance, adultery and social intercourse | 214 | |
Sudras and slaves in Manu | 216 | |
Manu's ban on social intercourse between the sudras and the brahmana | 220 | |
Marriage forms followed by the vaisyas and the sudras | 223 | |
Sudden increase in mixed castes in Manu | 225 | |
Untouchables in Manu | 227 | |
Manu on sudra's exclusion from Vedic studies and performance of religious rites | 230 | |
Some religious practices of the sudras and influence of Vaisnavism | 232 | |
Role of Sudras in the crisis reflected by the descriptions of the Kali age | 233 | |
Manu's violent anti-sudra measures | 236 | |
Signs of weakening in the servile status of the sudras | 240 | |
VII. | Peasanthood and Religious Rights (c.A.D. 300-600) | |
Sources for the Gupta period | 245 | |
Sudras as wage earners | 248 | |
Weakening of the slave system | 252 | |
Emergence of sudra peasants | 257 | |
Causes of the sudra peasanthood | 260 | |
Position of artisans | 262 | |
Sudra traders | 267 | |
The place of sudras in the political organization of the Gupta times | 268 | |
Continuance of varna distinctions in the administration of law and justice | 269 | |
Lessening of discriminations in the administration of criminal law and military recruitment | 274 | |
The sudra hostility to the existing social order | 279 | |
Some improvement in the social status of the sudra | 281 | |
Continuance of the brahmana boycott of the sudra's food | 283 | |
Food habits of the sudras | 285 | |
Marriage practices of the sudras | 286 | |
Mixed castes | 289 | |
The condition of the untouchables | 290 | |
Education of the sudras | 293 | |
Religious rights and sacraments for the sudras | 295 | |
Medieval texts on the social and religious conduct of the sudras | 305 | |
The sudra's right of making gifts | 306 | |
The contribution of Vaisnavism and Saivism to the religious elevation of the sudras | 307 | |
Significance of the enlargement of religious rights of the sudras | 312 | |
VIII | Change and Continuity | |
Main phases in history of the position of the sudras down to circa A.D.600 | 314 | |
Basic servility | 321 | |
Causes of the comparative calmness of the sudras | 322 | |
Appendix I Date of the Manu Smriti with Special Reference to the tenth Chapter | 327 | |
Appendix II Proliferation of Servile and Peasant Castes | 332 | |
Bibliography | 346 | |
Index (Sanskrit, Pali and Prakrit Words) | 369 | |
General Index | 374 |
Sudras in Ancient India tries to show how the labouring class in ancient times came to be known as sudras. It explores their social and economic relations with the members of the higher varnas. It also tries to tackle several other problems: Was ancient Indian society a slave society? How far did the ritual status of the sudras correspond to their economic status? How did the vaisyas come to be reduced to the level of the sudras and the sudras placed on a par with the vaisyas? What accounts for the proliferation of the servile orders in Gupta and post-Gupta times? Why were social revolts comparatively absent in ancient India?
Although the study hinges on the history of the sudras, it also works out a framework for the history of social differentiation and marks the main stages in the evolution of ancient Indian society. Since social history cannot be studied without appreciating material life, at various stages the impact of settled agricultural life, thriving trade, and land grants on the social formation has been made with developments in other ancient societies and also with tribal practices and institutions known to anthropology.
About the Author:
Professor R.S. Sharma (b. 1920) was mostly educated in the institutions affiliated to Patna University, under which he taught for 30 years till 1973 when he moved to Delhi University. He retired from Delhi University in 1985 and is now Emeritus Professor of History at Patna University. He did his Ph.D. at the School of Oriental and African Studies where he also served as a research associate. He was also a visiting professor at the University of Toronto. He was the first chairman of the Indian Council of Historical Research. His well-known book Ancient India (1977) was withdrawn by the Indian Government under the pressure of obscurantist elements in May 1978. Sharma's other publications include Indian Feudalism: 300-1200 (1980); Perspectives in Social and Economic History of Early India (1983); Material Culture and Social Formations In Ancient India (1983); Urban Decay in India (c. 300-c.1000), (1987); Communal History and Rama's Ayodhya (1992); Aspects of India Political Ideas and Institutions in Ancient India(1995); Looking for the Aryans (1995); The State and Varna Formation in the Mid-Ganga Plains (1996) and Early Medieval Indian Society (2001). His publications appear in fifteen languages, Indian and non-Indian.
Excerpts From Reviews:
This is an outstanding piece of research and authentic history of Sudras in ancient India. Professor Sharma has made use of all published sources, literary as well as archaeological, bearing on the social and economic position of Sudras. It gives a lucid and comprehensive account of all aspects of the anguished career of Sudra community.
L.M. Joshi
Journal of Religious Studies
Vol. 10, No. I & II, 1982
The facility and confidence with which Sharma makes his arguments and conclusions comforting, it weaves together scattered references into the first connected account of the Sudra varna and places this within a broader historical framework.
Upendra Singh
Contribution to Indian Sociology,
Vol.26, No.1, Jan-June, 1992
Sharma co-relates the phases of economic development with social organization and social change. He rightly calls the Rigvedic society as 'basically tribal', pastoral and egalitarian and 'a pre-class society' and contends that 'the defeated and disposed sections of Aryans and Non-aryan tribes were reduced to the position of Sudras'. The later-vedic society was food producing and agricultural, but their agricultural technology was primitive; consequently differentiation between haves and have-nots could not be intensified The Sudras continued to form the labour force of a labour-intensive economy; they also supplied surplus produce as peasants. There were no violent social upheavals because their minds were enchained by the Karma theory.
In ancient India, the cultural apparatus of the Sudras, more so of the untouchables or the 'asat' Sudra, was very primitive, consequently their response was usually of abject submission.
S.N. Mishra
The Eastern Anthropologist
Vol. 37, No. 4, Oct.-Dec. 1984
Preface to the Second Edition | v | |
Preface to the First Edition | vii | |
Abbreviations | ix | |
Roman Equivalents of Nagari letters | xiii | |
Chapters | ||
I. | Historiography and Approach | |
Western interest in ancient Indian society | 1 | |
The place of the sudras in writings on ancient society | 1 | |
Stating the questions and indicating the method | 3 | |
II. | Origin | |
Racial import of arya | 9 | |
Difference between the Dasas and Dasyus | 10 | |
Fight between the Aryan and the pre-Aryan tribes | 12 | |
Inter-tribal struggle among the Aryans | 16 | |
The Panis | 19 | |
Social adjustment between the Aryans and the pre-Aryan chalcolithic people | 21 | |
Das as 'Aryan' tribe/slave in the age of Rigveda | 24 | |
Mass migration of the Aryans attested by linguistic evidence and also by archaeology | 27 | |
Absence of sharp class divisions in Rigvedic society | 29 | |
High status of artisans | 31 | |
The Purusasukta and the sudras as a social order | 32 | |
Sudras as a tribe | 35 | |
Sudras as an Aryan tribe | 37 | |
Were the sudras originally ksatriyas? | 40 | |
Etymological derivation of the term sudra | 42 | |
The status of the sudra-varna at the time of its origin | 44 | |
III. | Tribes verses Varna (c. 1000 - 500 B.C.) | |
Later Vedic literature and Painted Grey Ware archaeology | 46 | |
Sudras as serving class | 48 | |
Sudras as 'serfs' and 'slaves' | 52 | |
Dignity of manual work | 53 | |
Sudras ratnins in the royal coronation | 54 | |
Sudras in the rajasuya rituals | 56 | |
Sudra soldiers in the asvamedha sacrifice | 59 | |
King's desire for the support of all the four varnas | 61 | |
Exclusion of the sudra from some coronation rituals | 62 | |
An Aitareya Brahmanapassage regarding the sudras | 64 | |
Marital relations between the higher varnas and sudras/slaves | 68 | |
Beginning of the assimilation of non-Aryan tribes | 71 | |
The sudra and upanayana | 73 | |
The sudra and Vedic sacrifice | 78 | |
Sudras's participation in some religious rites | 79 | |
Gods worshipped by the sudras | 81 | |
Greater evidence against the sudras participation in the Vedic sacrifice | 83 | |
Contradiction in the position of the sudras | 87 | |
Material culture and constraints on class formation | 88 | |
IV. | Servility and Disabilities (c. 600 - c. 300 B.C.) | |
Nature of the Dharmasutras and early Pali texts | 90 | |
Material background from NBP archaeology | 95 | |
Appropriation of land and labour | 96 | |
Clear definition of the sudras as a serving class | 98 | |
Crafts and craftsmen | 99 | |
Sudras as agricultural labourers | 102 | |
Slaves and hired labourers in production | 103 | |
Living conditions of the sudras | 106 | |
Dasas, pessas, kammakaras and bhatakas | 108 | |
Economic disabilities according to the Dharmasutras | 112 | |
Sudras as primary producers; their living standards | 114 | |
Comparison with Greek slaves and helots | 116 | |
Political-legal discriminations | 116 | |
Social disabilities | 124 | |
Exclusion from the rite of upanayana and from education | 133 | |
Exclusion from sacrifices and sacraments | 134 | |
Contempt of the higher varnas for manual occupations | 137 | |
Five despised castes of the early Pali texts | 138 | |
Origin of untouchability | 144 | |
Religious reforming movements and the sudras | 146 | |
End of the ambiguous position of the sudras | 152 | |
Sudras reaction to disabilities | 154 | |
V. | State Control and the Servile Order (c.300 - c. 200 B.C.) | |
The date and authenticity of the Arthasastra of Kautilya | 157 | |
The meaning of the term sudrakarsakapraya | 161 | |
Slaves and agricultural labourers in state production | 163 | |
Employment, control and wages of the artisans | 166 | |
High posts as the preserve of the three higher varnas | 172 | |
Sudras as spies and soldiers | 173 | |
Varna legislation of Kautilya | 174 | |
Status of the sudra vis-à-vis slaves in Kautilya | 177 | |
Dasa and ahitaka | 178 | |
Manumission and treatments of slaves | 179 | |
Mauryan society, a slave-owning society | 182 | |
Asoka's vyavahara-samata and danda-samata | 183 | |
Marriage practices of the sudras and the formation of mixed castes | 184 | |
Religious condition of the sudras | 187 | |
General conduct of the lower orders | 189 | |
VI. | Crisis in the Old Order (c. 200 B.C. - c. A.D. 300) | |
Sources for the post-Mauryan period | 191 | |
Manu on the approximation of the sudras with vaisyas | 192 | |
Artisans in the context of commerce and handicraft | 195 | |
Epigraphic and literary records on artisans | 199 | |
Manu's economic measures against the sudras | 201 | |
Wages and living conditions of the labourers | 204 | |
Adverse position of the sudras in law and polity | 207 | |
Severe punishments for sudras offending against members of the superior varnas | 211 | |
Discrimination against the sudra regarding inheritance, adultery and social intercourse | 214 | |
Sudras and slaves in Manu | 216 | |
Manu's ban on social intercourse between the sudras and the brahmana | 220 | |
Marriage forms followed by the vaisyas and the sudras | 223 | |
Sudden increase in mixed castes in Manu | 225 | |
Untouchables in Manu | 227 | |
Manu on sudra's exclusion from Vedic studies and performance of religious rites | 230 | |
Some religious practices of the sudras and influence of Vaisnavism | 232 | |
Role of Sudras in the crisis reflected by the descriptions of the Kali age | 233 | |
Manu's violent anti-sudra measures | 236 | |
Signs of weakening in the servile status of the sudras | 240 | |
VII. | Peasanthood and Religious Rights (c.A.D. 300-600) | |
Sources for the Gupta period | 245 | |
Sudras as wage earners | 248 | |
Weakening of the slave system | 252 | |
Emergence of sudra peasants | 257 | |
Causes of the sudra peasanthood | 260 | |
Position of artisans | 262 | |
Sudra traders | 267 | |
The place of sudras in the political organization of the Gupta times | 268 | |
Continuance of varna distinctions in the administration of law and justice | 269 | |
Lessening of discriminations in the administration of criminal law and military recruitment | 274 | |
The sudra hostility to the existing social order | 279 | |
Some improvement in the social status of the sudra | 281 | |
Continuance of the brahmana boycott of the sudra's food | 283 | |
Food habits of the sudras | 285 | |
Marriage practices of the sudras | 286 | |
Mixed castes | 289 | |
The condition of the untouchables | 290 | |
Education of the sudras | 293 | |
Religious rights and sacraments for the sudras | 295 | |
Medieval texts on the social and religious conduct of the sudras | 305 | |
The sudra's right of making gifts | 306 | |
The contribution of Vaisnavism and Saivism to the religious elevation of the sudras | 307 | |
Significance of the enlargement of religious rights of the sudras | 312 | |
VIII | Change and Continuity | |
Main phases in history of the position of the sudras down to circa A.D.600 | 314 | |
Basic servility | 321 | |
Causes of the comparative calmness of the sudras | 322 | |
Appendix I Date of the Manu Smriti with Special Reference to the tenth Chapter | 327 | |
Appendix II Proliferation of Servile and Peasant Castes | 332 | |
Bibliography | 346 | |
Index (Sanskrit, Pali and Prakrit Words) | 369 | |
General Index | 374 |